Great debates in economics: Keynes versus Hayek

The debates between John Maynard Keynes and Friedrich Hayek are some of the most significant economic debates. These two economists had very different ideas about how an economy should be managed and what policies most effectively promoted growth and stability.

Keynes and Hayek were both prominent economists during the early 20th century. Keynes was a British economist who believed in the power of government intervention in the economy. On the other hand, Hayek was an Austrian economist who believed in the power of the free market.

One of the key differences between Keynes and Hayek was their views on the role of government in the economy. Keynes believed that government intervention was necessary to promote economic growth and stability. He argued that government spending could boost demand during economic downturns, increasing employment and growth. This approach became known as Keynesian economics.

Hayek, however, believed that government intervention could harm the economy. He argued that the free market was the best way to allocate resources and promote economic growth. He believed government intervention could lead to inefficiencies, distortions, and even economic crises.

Another critical difference between Keynes and Hayek was their views on the business cycle. Keynes believed that a lack of aggregate demand caused the business cycle. He argued that government spending could boost demand during economic downturns and get the economy back on track.

On the other hand, Hayek believed that the misallocation of resources caused the business cycle. He argued that during economic booms, resources were misallocated, leading to a bust. Hayek believed the best way to prevent economic booms and busts was to let the free market work without government intervention.

The debate between Keynes and Hayek continues to this day. Many economists believe that both Keynesian and Hayekian policies have a role in managing the economy. For example, during times of economic downturn, government spending can help boost demand and prevent a recession. However, excessive government intervention can lead to inefficiencies and distortions in the market.

The debates between Keynes and Hayek have also highlighted the importance of understanding the complexities of the economy. There is no one-size-fits-all solution to economic management. Instead, economists must consider a range of factors, such as the state of the economy, the level of government debt, and the long-term consequences of policy decisions.

In conclusion, the debates between Keynes and Hayek have been instrumental in shaping economic thought and policy. While the two economists had very different views on the role of government in the economy, their ideas have contributed to a deeper understanding of the complexities of economic management. Today, economists continue to grapple with the challenges of managing the economy in a way that promotes growth, stability, and prosperity for all.

1.According to the Hayekian theory, which of the following is a key source of growth?

Savings that is used to finance investment

Government policy that is used to increase aggregate demand

Net exports that are equal to net imports

Rapid monetary expansion and artificially low interest rates

2.Jenna believes that an economy can achieve rapid economic progress if, instead of central planning and intervention by policy makers, the market process is allowed to coordinate the desires of consumers and producers. Jenna’s beliefs are most in line with the views of:

Marxism theory

Keynesian theory

Malthusian theory

Hayekian theory

3.Suppose the Federal Reserve expands credit availability leading to an artificially low interest rate in an economy. According to the Austrian view, which of the following is true?

It decreases the level of investment and encourages current consumption leading to a sustainable increase in aggregate demand

It should be offset by tax increases and cuts in government spending to avoid an increase in the national debt

It will lead to an economic boom fueled by malinvestment that will then later collapse into recession

The lower interest rate will help to stabilize the inherent fluctuations in investment caused by animal spirits

4.The critics of the Keynesian view believe that the Keynesian perspective does not:

address the issue of the instability of investment spending

take into account the fact that increased savings reduce consumption

take into account the shortcomings of the political process (government failure) and the secondary effects of government intervention

consider the benefits of government intervention that can stabilize inherent market instability

5.Suppose Raul thinks that markets are subject to widespread fluctuations based on unpredictable investment and that government intervention in the form of central planning, as well as fiscal and monetary policy can improve market outcomes. Raul’s beliefs are most in line with the views of:

Keynesian economics

Hayekian theory

Orwellian economics

Malthusian economics

6.According to the Hayekian theory, booms and busts are caused by:

fluctuations in exchange rates

perverse government policy

fluctuations in net exports

extreme fluctuations in private investment

7.Which of the following is true according to the Hayekians’ belief about the role of the government in an economy?

The government should do widespread central planning of production in the economy

The government should allocate and collectively own most resources in the economy

The government should provide the rule of law

The government should actively use monetary and fiscal policy to intervene in the economy to increase economic stability

8.Identify the correct statement.

The short-sightedness effect enables government intervention to improve market outcomes that involve investment

Lack of incentives for efficiency within government budgets is one source of government failure

The influence of special-interest groups increases the efficiency of government intervention to improve market outcomes

All economists agree on the ideal degree of government intervention into markets

9.Identify the correct statement about the Hayekian theory.

It argues that government intervention generally improves market efficiency and productivity

It argues that an increase in savings in an economy results in harmful economic effects because it decreases consumption spending in the economy

It argues that the structure of incentives and information problems lead to government failures and shortcomings that make it a poor corrective device

It argues that centralized planning in an economy results in an efficient allocation of resources

10.Much of the disagreement between Keynes and Hayek can be attributed to:

differing views of the effectiveness of markets versus the political process in coordinating economic activity

a disagreement over whether economic stability was desirable

the fact that they were never at the same university at the same time

one favoring more widespread use of countercyclical fiscal policy while the other favored more widespread use of countercyclical monetary policy

11.Which of the following is likely to be true when there is an increase in savings in an economy?

It will reduce investment in an economy

It will increase the level of unemployment in an economy

It will lower real interest rates in an economy

It will increase the national debt in an economy

12.The paradox of thrift refers to the situation in which:

if everyone tries to work during a recession, there will be a reduction in wages and prices, causing aggregate demand to fall

countries with an abundance of nonrenewable resources tend to have lower rates of economic growth than countries with fewer natural resources

if individuals increase their savings, the economy will be harmed because the savings will drain funds away from consumption spending

high-income countries do not have a high ranking in the human development index

13.According to the Hayekian theory, economic booms are the result of:

excessive tax increases in an economy

too little savings and too much consumption

excessive credit expansion in an economy

large reductions in the money supply

14.According to the Austrian school of economics, which of the following is a key determinant of the time structure of capital and the length of the production process?

The interest rate in an economy

The wise use of government central planning

Whether imports are equal to exports

The inherent instability of a market economy

15.Identify the correct statement about the Keynesian theory.

According to the Keynesian theory, central planners do not have sufficient information to improve market outcomes

According to the Keynesian theory, centralized planning leads to market failure

According to the Keynesian theory, intervention by policy-makers can improve market outcomes

According to the Keynesian theory, a spontaneous order emerges from the market process that coordinates the desires of consumers and producers efficiently and with stability

16.Keynesians would believe which of the following statements is true?

Market economies are inherently unstable and government intervention can promote economic stability

A higher rate of savings accomplished by reducing consumption will promote economic prosperity by encouraging investment

Economic instability is primarily the result of malinvestment generated by improper government monetary and credit expansion

Policymakers do not have the information or incentives to plan the economy effectively and doing so is far less efficient than allocation through markets

17.Keynesian theory stresses:

the importance of cutting consumption to increase savings and investment

the potential shortcomings of government intervention

the role of aggregate demand and spending in the macroeconomy

the inherent stability of a market economy

18.Hayekian theory stresses:

the importance of market prices and institutions and the shortcomings of political intervention

the potential advantages of using monetary policy to hold interest rates low

the importance of government management of aggregate demand and spending in the macroeconomy to promote stability

the inherent instability of a market economy

19.According to the Hayekian theory, malinvestment refers to:

the sale of non-performing assets by the government to purchase ones that will perform better

the decrease in the level of investment caused by an increase in savings

inefficient investments that are unprofitable and unsustainable in the future caused by government artificially holding interest rates too low

purchasing government bonds that are used to finance a deficit

20.Which of the following would be supported by a Keynesian economist if the economy were in a recession?

An increase in private savings accomplished through reductions in private consumption

An increase in tax rates and a budget surplus

The government doing nothing, leave the economy alone to fix itself

An increase in government spending financed by a budget deficit

Great debates in economics: Keynes versus Hayek

Great debates in economics: Keynes versus Hayek

You May Also Like

Creating an environment for growth and prosperity

IELTS пробный тест по словарному запасу 97. Готовимся к сдаче тестирования

Leave a comment Cancel reply